Compelling energy deal, stalling at credit committee? How to Give Your Committee Confidence in Renewable Energy Collateral

Date :
13/10/2026

When a solid renewable energy deal stalls at committee, the collateral section is usually why. A look at what credit officers need to see, and how to give it to them.

If you work on an energy desk, you've probably lived this before. The sponsor is solid, the revenue is contracted and the coverage ratios work. The deal still comes back from committee with another round of questions, and most of them are about the collateral.

Frustrating, but fair. Every secured loan has a primary source of repayment, usually the project's cash flow, and a secondary source, usually the collateral. Committees have to weigh both. The OCC has also noted that when a credit weakens, analysis shifts to the secondary sources and the potential loss, and collateral carries more weight in the risk rating. Credit officers know that, so they ask.

With renewable energy, lenders have gotten good at underwriting the primary source. The secondary source is where files tend to run thin, and for the first time that's a fixable problem.

Why collateral is the harder question for renewables

Lenders have plenty of tools for energy project cash flow analysis: offtake contracts, coverage ratios, independent engineer reports. The underlying collateral is a different story, and mostly because there hasn’t been acceptable data, standards, and benchmarks to use.

Start with history. In energy storage, project finance lenders view newer technologies as riskier because there's so little historical data to lean on. Few banks have a stack of completed recoveries to benchmark against.

Then there's the evolving energy resale market. U.S. secondary market prices for solar modules tend to run 20% to 70% below primary market prices, and used and legacy modules made up only 2% of resale supply on one major exchange in 2025. Technology moves fast, too. PERC module resale values held steady in 2025 but are expected to slide as N-type supply takes over, so equipment can lose its buyers before it wears out.

Output also drifts down over time. The National Laboratory of the Rockies, formerly NREL, reviewed nearly 2,000 field measurements and put the median solar degradation rate at 0.5% per year. A later study by the lab of nearly 8 GW of U.S. commercial and utility-scale solar found that systems in hotter climates lost performance about twice as fast as those in cooler ones, and its researchers noted that the degradation rate is used in almost all solar financing agreements. And once equipment is bolted to a pad or racked in a field, someone has to pay to get it out before it can be sold.

Renewable collateral can still be solid collateral with material residual value. It just behaves differently from the kinds of assets many credit policies were written around, so the usual shortcuts don't translate well.

[Download the Credit Committee Checklist]

Where collateral sections usually come up short

When the collateral section is thin, there's usually a reasonable explanation. The data is hard to find and the deal team is already stretched. A few residual value gaps show up again and again.

Cost stands in for value. Contract price or estimated replacement cost is the easiest number to pull, so it often becomes a substitute for the collateral value by default. The trouble is that cost tells the committee what the equipment was worth to the buyer on day one. It says nothing about what the bank could get for it in a rushed sale after paying to have it removed.

End-of-life costs are a range, not a number. In solar, for example, a 2025 Buckstop analysis of decommissioning bonds for 13 projects across 10 states, 2.2 GW in total, found that cost estimates were fairly consistent: 62% fell between $47,000 and $57,000 per MW. Salvage value estimates were not. They ranged from $3,486 to $198,669 per MW, and even with the highest and lowest removed, the spread ran from $13,354 to $107,148 per MW. Put one of those estimates in front of a committee and the first question is how much to trust it.

Enforcement takes work with material cost implications. Taking possession of a renewable asset means arranging removal, haul and disconnection, and paying for all of it. With battery storage, lenders also need access to the system's software if they exercise remedies and take ownership of the project. Every step costs money and time, and both represent significant deductions from any value recovery efforts.

A worked example: how collateral value moves through a project

Collateral value fluctuates during a project, sometimes by wide margins. This trend is accelerating with supply chain vulnerabilities, tariffs, and geo-political instability.. A recent valuation of a Midwest battery storage portfolio (10 Tesla Megapack 2XL units, 38,540 kWh) shows how much it can shift between delivery and installation.

Net recovery here is the forced-sale value minus the cost of removing the units.

Once the units were installed, net recovery dropped 34%. They were no longer new in the box, and the project didn't yet have a revenue history that would let someone buy it as an operating business. Removal alone (crane, heavy haul, electrical disconnect) came to about $101,000, or $2.62 per kWh. Timing mattered too: an orderly sale of the installed units was estimated at 9 to 18 months, a forced sale at 6 to 8.

See the Valuation Matrix

The same logic holds for other renewable assets. Installation adds a removal bill and takes away the new-equipment premium, and value doesn't recover until the project has a revenue record. If the committee can see that curve, it can time reserves, covenants or draws around the low point.

The same deal, two credit memos

Picture a construction loan for a utility-scale solar project paired with battery storage. The sponsor is experienced, the offtake is contracted and the coverage ratios clear the bank's thresholds. The cash flow side of the memo is strong. Approval now depends on the collateral section.

Memo A raises more questions than it answers. What would the bank get back before COD? Who came up with the number? What happens if the project stalls halfway through construction? It's the kind of file that goes back for another round.

Memo B gives the committee something to work with. It can set the advance rate against realistic recovery, time a reserve or draw schedule to the period before COD when collateral value is lowest, and add a covenant requiring updated values at COD. The risk is the same in both memos. In the second one, it's visible.

If a loan runs into trouble: liquidation and workouts

The collateral section matters most in the scenario everyone hopes to avoid. It helps to think through what the bank's options would actually look like.

Liquidation scenarios. If the bank takes possession of the equipment, recovery depends on how it gets sold.

The worked example above shows how far apart these outcomes can be. The same equipment produced different recovery values depending on project stage and who paid for removal.[9]

Workouts: Liquidation tends to be the last resort. When a borrower runs into trouble, banks often try a workout first, working with the borrower to restructure the loan rather than take the collateral. Federal banking regulators have encouraged banks to work prudently and constructively with creditworthy borrowers during times of financial stress.

In renewable energy, a workout might look like:

  • Extending the construction period or maturity when COD slips because of an interconnection or equipment delay.
  • Temporary payment relief while the sponsor resolves a performance problem or a warranty claim.
  • A recapitalization, where new equity comes in or another sponsor buys the project and takes on the loan.
  • A sale or redeployment of equipment that hasn't been installed yet.

Each option comes with a trade-off the bank has to weigh against liquidation. That comparison only works if the bank knows what the collateral is worth right now, under each path. A collateral value from closing day, sometimes years old, won't support that decision.

What gives a committee confidence

Committees don't expect certainty on collateral. What they want is evidence that someone has thought it through. In practice, that means the file answers a handful of questions:

  1. What would the bank actually recover? Market value, orderly liquidation sale, forced-liquidation value and net recovery after removal, not just replacement cost.
  2. How does that change over the loan? Values at each project stage, so the committee can see where exposure is highest.
  3. What does enforcement cost? Removal, decommissioning and disposal priced line by line, with salvage credited conservatively.
  4. How long would a sale take? Realistic timelines for an orderly sale and a forced sale, so carrying costs and reserves are grounded.
  5. Where do the numbers come from? Cited sources and real comparable transactions behind each value, not just a stated method, so reviewers and examiners can follow the logic.
  6. Who prepared them? Independence matters. Values prepared by a party with a stake in the deal, such as the developer or equipment owner, tend to carry less weight than an independent third-party valuation.
  7. What is current, and what is projected? Current values and future-stage values labeled separately, each with an as-of date.

Answering these won't take the risk out of a renewable energy loan. It puts that risk where the committee can see it and price it, which is usually what a committee needs before it says yes.

Collateral Value Doesn't Stay Static

Collateral analysis is most useful when it lives past closing day. Set values at underwriting, update them as the project hits each milestone, and you'll have a current number ready if a loan ever ends up in workout.

Collateral analysis is most useful when it lives past closing day. Set values at underwriting, update them as the project hits each milestone, and you'll have a current number ready if a loan ever ends up in workout.

A recent Buckstop valuation of a 38,540 kWh battery storage portfolio illustrates why this matters. Net recovery value fell from $3.43 million before installation to $2.28 million after installation, a 34% decline, even though the equipment's replacement cost remained $5.28 million. Having visibility into these changes helps lenders assess collateral exposure and make more informed decisions throughout the loan lifecycle.

That's the work Buckstop does with lenders. If you've got a renewable energy deal coming up and want to see what a committee-ready collateral analysis looks like, we're happy to walk you through one.

Let’s Talk!

‍

‍

Author
  • Kristen Shaw

    She brings extensive experience in technology marketing, with her 20+ year of experience. Kristen is also the National Marketing Chair for Cleantech Open and is actively involved in the climate technology community. At Buckstop, her work focuses on helping asset owners, lenders, insurers, and investors better understand the value of renewable energy infrastructure throughout its lifecycle.‍

    LinkedIn